While all three (X12 997, EDIFACT CONTRL, and MDN) serve as acknowledgements in electronic data interchange, they operate at different levels and have distinct purposes:
1. X12 997 (Functional Acknowledgment)
Standard: ANSI X12 (primarily used in North America).
Level: Application/Functional Level Acknowledgement.
Purpose: The 997 is an electronic "receipt" that confirms the receipt and processing of an EDI transaction set (e.g., a Purchase Order 850, an Invoice 810).
It signifies that the receiving system's EDI translator successfully opened the EDI envelope and validated the contents according to the X12 standard. What it confirms:
The message was received.
The message was structurally and syntactically valid according to the X12 standard and often, the trading partner's specific guidelines.
It can indicate acceptance, acceptance with errors, or rejection of the entire transaction set or specific segments/elements within it, providing specific error codes.
What it DOES NOT confirm: It does not confirm that the recipient has accepted the business content of the document (e.g., agreeing to the price on an invoice, or confirming stock availability for a purchase order).
That's a business-level acknowledgement, often communicated through other EDI messages (like an 855 Purchase Order Acknowledgement for an 850 Purchase Order). Analogy: Think of it like receiving a package, opening it, and confirming all items listed on the packing slip are present and undamaged. You're not necessarily saying you're happy with the order or that you'll keep everything, just that you received what was sent.
2. EDIFACT CONTRL (Syntax and Service Report Message)
Standard: UN/EDIFACT (globally used, especially in Europe and Asia).
Level: Both Technical and Functional Level Acknowledgement.
Purpose: The CONTRL message is more comprehensive than the 997. It reports the results of the syntax and service validation of a received EDIFACT interchange, functional group, or message.
It can act as a technical acknowledgement (receipt confirmation) and a functional acknowledgement (syntax validation and error reporting). What it confirms:
Technical: Confirms the receipt of the interchange and can indicate if there were issues with the envelope (e.g., character set errors, duplicate interchange).
Functional: Confirms structural and syntactic validity of the contained messages, groups, and elements. It can provide detailed error codes for rejections or issues at various levels of the EDIFACT message structure.
Analogy: It's like receiving a complex document, checking that it arrived intact (technical) and then thoroughly reviewing its format, grammar, and sentence structure (functional) to ensure it adheres to predefined rules.
3. MDN (Message Disposition Notification)
Standard: Primarily associated with AS2 (Applicability Statement 2), a secure and reliable protocol for transmitting EDI messages over the internet.
Level: Communication/Transport Level Acknowledgement.
Purpose: The MDN confirms the successful delivery and processing at the communication protocol level. It's about the secure and reliable transmission of the AS2 message itself, not the EDI content within it.
What it confirms:
The AS2 message was successfully received by the trading partner's AS2 system.
The message was decrypted (if encrypted).
The digital signature was verified (if signed), ensuring message integrity and non-repudiation.
What it DOES NOT confirm: It does not confirm that the EDI document inside the AS2 envelope was syntactically correct or that the recipient's EDI system could process the business content.
Types: Can be synchronous (sent back on the same HTTP connection) or asynchronous (sent back in a separate HTTP transaction).
Analogy: This is like getting a "delivery confirmation" from a courier service. It tells you the package arrived at its destination and was signed for, but not what the recipient thought of the contents inside.
Key Differences Summarized:
Feature | X12 997 (Functional Acknowledgment) | EDIFACT CONTRL (Syntax & Service Report) | MDN (Message Disposition Notification) |
Standard | ANSI X12 (North America) | UN/EDIFACT (Global) | AS2 (Communication Protocol) |
Level | Application/Functional | Technical & Functional | Communication/Transport Level |
What it Confirms | Syntax/Structure of EDI content | Syntax/Structure of EDI content & Interchange receipt | Delivery, Integrity, & Authenticity of the AS2 message |
Scope | EDI Transaction Set(s) | EDI Interchange, Functional Group, or Message | The AS2 message envelope |
Purpose | Receipt and syntactic validity of the EDI document | Receipt, syntactic, and service validation of EDI | Proof of delivery for the secure transmission |
Analogy | Opening a package and checking packing slip | Receiving and reviewing a complex document | Delivery confirmation from a courier |
In an end-to-end EDI flow, you would typically see an MDN first, confirming the successful AS2 transmission.
No comments:
Post a Comment